v. OTW will place a prominent announcement on the Open Doors page indicating that the original maintainer has moved to a new location, with a link to the new location if provided by the maintainer.
vi. OTW may choose to continue work on the collection on the OTW servers.
To me, these clauses are both pretty darn problematic.
For section v, I think that an announcement that the original maintainer has moved should also appear on the pages [project].tw.org and opendoors.tw.org/[project], and they should be equally as prominent as what appears on the Open Doors page.
For section vi, I am honestly pretty opposed to OTW continuing to work on the collection in general, but, at the very least, I want a lot more clarity on what 'continue to work on the collection' means. Is this simple maintenance work, where if people submit stories which qualify for the collection, a collection maintainer will approve their inclusion? Or is OTW going to actively solicit content for the collection, in some sense competing with the original maintainer's project which is now spun off elsewhere? Is there going to be any distinction between work added under the auspice of the original maintainer and that added under the new OTW management?
P.S. For clarification, I am speaking as a general member of fandom, not as a member of the Webmasters' Committee. However, this website only provides one icon per account, and I have the webmasters' one to be clear when posting announcements.
Open Doors TOS
v. OTW will place a prominent announcement on the Open Doors page indicating that the original maintainer has moved to a new location, with a link to the new location if provided by the maintainer.
vi. OTW may choose to continue work on the collection on the OTW servers.
To me, these clauses are both pretty darn problematic.
For section v, I think that an announcement that the original maintainer has moved should also appear on the pages [project].tw.org and opendoors.tw.org/[project], and they should be equally as prominent as what appears on the Open Doors page.
For section vi, I am honestly pretty opposed to OTW continuing to work on the collection in general, but, at the very least, I want a lot more clarity on what 'continue to work on the collection' means. Is this simple maintenance work, where if people submit stories which qualify for the collection, a collection maintainer will approve their inclusion? Or is OTW going to actively solicit content for the collection, in some sense competing with the original maintainer's project which is now spun off elsewhere? Is there going to be any distinction between work added under the auspice of the original maintainer and that added under the new OTW management?
P.S. For clarification, I am speaking as a general member of fandom, not as a member of the Webmasters' Committee. However, this website only provides one icon per account, and I have the webmasters' one to be clear when posting announcements.